| Category |
4 |
3 |
2 |
1 |
0 |
| Spelling
(points x 1) |
No spelling mistakes. |
1-2 spelling mistakes and not distracting to the reader. |
3-4 spelling mistakes and somewhat distracting. |
5 spelling mistakes and somewhat distracting. |
> 5 spelling mistakes and no proofreading obvious. |
| Grammar
(points x 1) |
No grammatical mistakes. |
1-2 grammatical mistakes and not distracting to the reader. |
3-4 grammatical mistakes and somewhat distracting. |
5 grammatical mistakes and somewhat distracting. |
> 5 grammatical mistakes and no proofreading obvious |
| Introduction
(points x 2) |
Includes title & author, publication data (publisher,
year, # of pages), genre, and what book's about. |
Missing one element of introduction. |
Missing two elements of introduction. |
Missing 3 or more elements of introduction. |
No introduction. |
| Description of Book
(Fiction Only)
(points x 3) |
Includes thorough description of setting, time period, main
character, and plot. |
Adequate description of setting, time period, main
character, and plot. |
Inaccurate or incomplete description of one of: setting,
time period, main character, or plot. |
Inaccurate or incomplete description of more than one of:
setting, time period, main character, or plot. |
No description of book. |
| Description of Book
(Nonfiction Only)
(points x 3) |
Includes thorough summary of book's subject and summary of
author's main points. |
Adequate summary of book's subject and summary of author's
main points. |
Inaccurate or incomplete summary of one of: book's subject
or summary of author's main points. |
Inaccurate or incomplete summary of both of book's subject
and summary of author's main points. |
No description of book. |
| Analysis of Book
(points x 3) |
Includes at least six strong points of analysis or critique,
supported with examples. |
Includes at least six points of adequate analysis or
critique, supported with examples. |
Includes at least six points of weak analysis or critique or
adequate points not supported with examples. |
Includes fewer than six points of analysis or critique or no
points supported with examples. |
No analysis or critique of book. |
| Conclusion
(points x 1) |
Concise and accurate summary of main impression or points of
book. |
Adequate summary of main impression or points of book. |
Incomplete or incorrect summary of main impression or points
of book. |
Conclusion addresses points not in description or analysis. |
No conclusion. |